24 Eternal Prepper Debates That Keep Raging On

Ever notice how some prepper debates never seem to die? These endless arguments keep resurfacing no matter how many times they’re hashed out.

Debates about whether to bug out or hunker down and the necessity of firearms in survival gear remain fiercely contested. Each side has passionate advocates and compelling arguments.

We’re exploring the enduring nature of these perennial prepper debates. Whether you’re a seasoned prepper or just curious, understanding these ongoing controversies will illuminate the complexities of survival strategies.

1. Bugging Out vs. Staying Put

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Debates in the prepper community often focus on whether to evacuate or stay put in a crisis.

Supporters of evacuation recommend swiftly moving to a well-stocked haven, while those who favor staying home argue for safety in a prepared residence. 

Factors like the type of disaster, location, resources, personal circumstances, and caring for family, including children and elderly, impact decision-making.

2. What to Add to Bug Out Bag

Get home bag
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Preppers agree that having a well-stocked bug-out bag is crucial in case of an evacuation. 

But what they disagree on is what you should include in it. 

Some suggest prioritizing essentials like food, water, shelter, and first aid in a bug-out bag. In contrast, others recommend adding weapons, self-defense gear, communication devices, tools for survival tasks, and essential documents. 

3. The Role Guns

door lock, safety, protection
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

The topic of guns can be a sensitive one within the prepper community. 

Some believe that having firearms is essential for protection during a disaster or crisis, while others argue that relying on guns can cause more harm than good.

Even if you go for a firearm in your preparedness, it’s still crucial to have other self-defense options like pepper spray, batons, or some basic martial arts skills.

4. Home Grown or Store Bought?

vegetable garden
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

One of the biggest debates among preppers is whether to grow their own food or stockpile store-bought items. 

Growing your own food can be cost-effective and sustainable; it requires time, space, and knowledge.

Stocking up on store-bought items provides an immediate supply of essentials, though it may lack reliability during long-term disasters.

5. Freeze Dried or Canned Food?

canned vegetables
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Regarding food storage, the debate between freeze-dried and canned food is ongoing. 

Freeze-dried food is lightweight, has a longer shelf life, and retains more nutrients than canned food. 

However, canned food is more affordable and readily available at grocery stores.

6. Cash or Precious Metals?

small gold nuggets
Photo Credit: Shutterstock.

Preppers debate the value of having money or precious metals during a disaster because

money may lose its value in an economic collapse, making it useless for purchasing supplies, but in some cases, cash would make it easier to buy necessary items.

While precious metals such as gold and silver have inherent value that you can use for bartering in a post-disaster economy, they are not as handy for purchasing items as cash.

7. Community or Alone?

small-group-of-people
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Relying heavily on a community means trusting others with your safety and well-being, which can be daunting for some. 

However, while being part of a community can provide valuable resources and support during difficult times, some preppers prefer to rely on themselves and their own skills to survive. 

8. Barter or Save Supplies

young-woman-volunteering
Photo Credit: Shutterstock.

Should you use your stockpile items to barter with or use them only for survival? This question divides the prepper community.

Some argue that using supplies for bartering helps to build relationships and establish a supportive community. 

In contrast, others believe it is important to save all resources for their own survival needs.

9. Discuss or Secret

couple speaking to neighbors
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

One of the major debates among preppers is whether to talk about their beliefs and preparations with others openly. 

Sharing information and resources can help a community, but it also carries the risk of being seen as a target by those looking to take advantage of your preparedness.

10. Help Zombies or Consider Them a Threat

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

After a catastrophic event, unprepared individuals may seek help, with some preppers showing compassion to these “zombies” while others perceive them as a threat. 

Discussions also emerge on whether to assist the underprepared if they are loved ones by sharing resources or focusing on self-defense.

11. Gear or Skills

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Preppers often debate whether to prioritize gear or survival skills. 

While having the right equipment is advantageous, mastering the skills to use them effectively is equally crucial. 

They emphasize learning critical survival skills such as first aid, navigation, and food preservation.

12. What Events to Prepare For

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Common events that preppers prepare for include natural disasters such as hurricanes, earthquakes, wildfires, pandemics, and man-made disasters like economic collapse or social unrest, but which ones should you prepare for is the question.

Some preppers prepare for worst-case scenarios, while others focus on more realistic and likely events; however, a well-thought-out preparedness plan can help mitigate the impact and increase the chances of survival.

13. Bows or Guns

bow and arrow
Image credit: Shutterstock.

The prepper community often debates bows versus guns for hunting and self-defense. 

Guns pack more power and range, but bows bring silence and independence from ammo needs. 

Choosing between them depends on personal preference, local laws, and your training with each weapon.

14. MREs or Home Made Meals

Woman Meal Planning
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

While MREs (Meals Ready to Eat) are popular for emergency food supplies, they can be expensive and not very appetizing.

Many preppers prefer to make their own meals from dehydrated or canned foods, incorporating homegrown fruits and vegetables into their diet, allowing for more variety and control over the ingredients used and potentially saving money in the long run.

15. Ways to Store Food

A couple selects food items from bulk bins at an eco-friendly grocery store, emphasizing zero waste shopping.
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

How and where to store food has been a debate amongst preppers for years, and properly storing food can make all the difference in an emergency situation.

Some popular methods include using Mylar bags with oxygen absorbers, vacuum sealing, canning, and storing in a cool and dry place like a root cellar or pantry. 

16. How to Purify Water

Filtering water
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

In addition to food, having access to clean drinking water is crucial in an emergency, but what is the best way to purify your water? 

Some preppers think boiling or using water filters is the best and simplest way, while others recommend purification tablets and even building a solar still.

17. Growing Your Own Food?

older people gardening
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Should you learn to grow your own food or stockpile enough to last for years?

While stockpiling food can provide immediate relief and security in the event of an emergency, relying solely on stored items may not be sustainable in the long run.

Growing your own food can provide a continuous source of fresh produce and give you valuable skills that can be used even in non-emergency situations.

18. Join a Prepper Network?

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Preppers discuss the benefits of joining a prepper network for emergency resources and support. 

While some see the value in community, shared knowledge, and pooling resources, others worry about trust issues and conflicts. 

It’s a question of group security versus trusting their preparations.

19. How to Store Water

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Water is essential for survival, but how to store it is often a debate for preppers.

Some recommend buying bottled water or large containers and storing tap water, while others prefer collecting rainwater or filtering it from natural sources.

Regardless of the method, it’s important to have a plan for storing and filtering water in an emergency.

20. How Much to Stockpile

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

When it comes to stockpiling supplies, opinions vary among preppers. 

Some advocate hoarding as much as possible, while others prioritize storing within practical limits based on individual needs and resources, considering storage space, budget, and the specific disaster scenario.

21. Bunker or No Bunker?

bunker
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Building a bunker is a popular topic among preppers and survivalists. 

Still, some think it is unnecessary and a waste of resources, while others see it as a crucial addition to their survival plan. 

The decision to build a bunker should be based on individual circumstances, and weighing the costs and benefits is important.

22. Wood or Propane?

firewood
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Many preppers debate whether wood or propane is the best fuel source for cooking and heating during an emergency. 

Wood is often seen as a more sustainable option, as it can be easily sourced from forests or even your backyard, but it requires proper storage and maintenance to ensure it stays dry and ready for use. 

On the other hand, propane is a cleaner-burning fuel that can provide consistent heat and is easy to store in large quantities. 

23. Animals

chickens
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

When preparing for emergencies, preppers must decide whether animals should be part of their readiness plan. 

In crises, livestock can provide food, companionship, and security, but caring for them requires extra resources and may hinder mobility during evacuations. 

Evaluating your area and the likely disasters before involving animals in your emergency preparations is essential.

24. Communication

cb-radio
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

When communicating in a crisis, preppers have a lot to say. 

Some swear by radios and walkie-talkies for reliability, while others opt for satellite phones or CB radios. 

The key is to have different communication options ready in case one fails during an emergency.

23 Riskiest Cities To Be During a Power Grid Collapse

In a world where the stability of our power grid is increasingly under threat, knowing which urban areas to avoid during a blackout is crucial for any serious prepper. And which areas to escape as quickly as possible. When you’re making your survival plans, keep in mind that these are the places you don’t want to be.

New york at night
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

20 Crucial Supplies for Surviving a Societal Collapse

glass of water
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

In the face of uncertainty, being well-prepared gives you at least some degree of control and security. The thought of a societal collapse, while extreme, prompts us to consider how we might endure without the conveniences of our current lifestyle. Here’s a list of 20 essential items that could prove indispensable in such a scenario. This guide isn’t about succumbing to fear but embracing preparedness and resilience.

12 Money Mistakes That Can Leave You Vulnerable in a Crisis

money in an emergency fund jar
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

In times of uncertainty, financial stability is more crucial than ever. While prepping for physical emergencies is vital, don’t overlook financial prepping. Avoiding these common money mistakes can help make sure you’re in a stronger position to weather any storm.

+ posts

Leave a Comment