Can You Freeze Mushrooms at Home? You Bet You Can!

You know that time that you are looking at a local grocery ad and seeing mushrooms on sale for and you squeal? You just might be a food storage junkie! If so, it is always helpful to know how to freeze mushrooms in order to can consume them anytime!

When Aldi’s has a mushroom sale, I stock up HUGE! It’s not unlike me to call and reserve 3-4 trays (each tray holds 12 8oz packages) to bring home because they prefer you don’t purchase that many at once just walking into the store. However, this doesn’t mean that you can’t do it. They won’t turn up their noses at your money, they just want to make sure you aren’t clearing their shelves for other customers.

I also find mushrooms on clearance at our local Kroger fairly often and grab those as I can as well. I usually dehydrate these as they may be nearing the end of their useable shelf life if we don’t cook them immediately.

Finding ways to preserve our food when we find great grocery deals, have an overabundance of garden bounty, or find ourselves with loads from u-pick-it farms, is one of the biggest day-to-day tasks that I have for our family. I don’t limit myself to pre-packaged freeze-dried foods or simply dehydrating or canning, but I also include in the equation!

For the moment, I’ll be talking about the cultivated mushrooms most people know as white button mushrooms or the brown crimini mushrooms. There are a ton of varieties of mushrooms and these general guidelines will be good for them, but they each have their own distinctive characteristics.

Tips for Buying Fine Mushrooms for Freezing

Different types of mushrooms
  • Look for a clean smell. You shouldn’t be smelling something that is musty or moldy, but woodsy and fresh.
  • Look for firm flesh, not flakey (for general broad mushrooms as the varieties are many and textures can be different in a healthy mushroom), and not bruised or discolored.
  • The gills (underside) should be closed and not black when you purchase them (they may as they continue growing even after harvest, so you want the freshest you can get when you purchase).
  • The surfaces of the mushroom should be dry, but not dried out, and appear plump.
  • A closed veil under the mushroom cap indicates a delicate flavor, while an open veil and exposed gills mean a richer flavor.
  • How do pre-sliced mushrooms hold up to whole ones? Since sliced mushrooms have more surfaces exposed to air, they don’t keep as long as whole ones. This does not mean sliced mushrooms are inferior. It just means you need to take extra care when selecting them to make sure what’s in the carton is in good shape (clean, firm, etc.), and then try to use them within a few days of purchase. However, you should not use them for freezing or storing a long period of time.

How to Store Mushrooms for Short Term Usage [Alternative to Freeze Mushrooms]

There are so many ways suggested to store mushrooms such as in paper bags, in damp paper towels, and lightly wrapped in plastic. Although, I prefer to just keep them in their original container until use. Because I rarely open a container and don’t use the whole thing, I don’t worry about storing an opened container. I just wrap again in plastic wrap and put a few holes to allow air movement and less sweating to help preserve them longer.

  • So, DO store loose mushrooms in a partially open zipper-lock bag, which maximizes air circulation without drying out the mushrooms. Leaving the bag slightly open allows for the release of the ethylene gas emitted from the mushrooms.
  • As well as, DO store packaged mushrooms in their original containers. These containers are designed to “breathe,’’ maximizing the life of the mushrooms by balancing the retention of moisture and release of ethylene gas.
  • Finally, DON’T wrap mushrooms in a paper bag, as many other sources suggest. It turns the fungi spongy and wrinkly. My experience thought me that this is a terrible advice.

We normally all the mushrooms we won’t be eating in the next 3 days (I will sautée them as a side dish or for mushroom swiss burgers or for other beef and mushroom meals). It’s a quick and easy process and preserves both the dehydrated mushroom and . But I have another great way to preserve mushrooms – I freeze them!

How to Freeze Mushrooms With Mom With A Prep

You can freeze a variety of mushrooms in their raw state, but I don’t really like the end product as well as I like it when I do this variety. We save the fancier mushrooms for using fresh and raw or rehydrated for meals but will freeze the button mushrooms a lot for inclusion into dishes like spaghetti sauces, stews, etc.

Clean the Mushrooms

Rinse under water and allow to dry in the open air on a tea towel. YES, you can do it. Alton Brown proved it through an experiment on his show Good Eats that mushrooms only absorb a negligible amount of moisture in this process, which is so much faster than the next. The only issue is your dehydrated and frozen mushrooms will be a little browner as an end product, but it doesn’t affect their flavor at all.

Brush off with either a towel or a mushroom brush.

Slice the Mushrooms

You’ll need to slice your mushrooms in a uniform size if you can, and about 1/4″ will do.

I have played around with using an egg slicer to slice my mushrooms, but as you’ll see, because our mushrooms were just a tad less than perfectly firm, it killed my original egg slicer because I was a little too hard on the first slice.

slice mushrooms

So I had to go out and buy a new egg slicer to replace it.

There are some specific (but I’m not a big fan of unitaskers) out there. There are also some  (this model has blades instead of wires which will work much better), or you could use an that does everything. If your mushrooms are super firm, this can work and save a lot of time. However, it’s best to go ahead and just get the knife out and make a party out of it!

Sautée the Mushrooms

sautee mushrooms

I get a fairly hot pan going and let those mushrooms carmelize a bit and then lower the heat a little and allow the mushrooms to cook. I use a little butter and oil mixture to help keep things from sticking, but you don’t want to use too much. Butter has a lot of moisture and you don’t want the ‘shrooms having to deal with that as well. Once the mushrooms have released their moisture, I tend to turn the pan up just a bit to help get rid of it.

You can also add a bit of salt to the pan once the mushrooms have turned this ‘translucent’ color, as it will help facilitate the moisture reduction, but for freezing, I skip that step.

Freeze the Mushrooms

Lay your cooled mushrooms out on a tray, single layer, and ‘flash freeze’ in the freezer

freeze mushrooms

This is what they look like when they come out. The “frost” you see is not freezer burn, but the tiny layer of frost that they get when you first pull them out. You’ll want to act quickly to move on to the next step because they do begin to thaw fairly quickly on the surface, which will make them tend to stick together once you do the final storage.

freeze mushrooms

Store the Mushrooms

store mushrooms

I store my mushrooms in 1C quantities in individual bags, then store them in a larger bag. I remove all the I can from each bag to help keep them from getting freezer burn. When I’m ready to use it, I can just pull out a bag and toss the contents into a sauce.

It’s that easy!

Your Thoughts On Freeze Mushrooms

Finally, it’s time for you to share all your thoughts on this topic. Tell us everything about your experience when buying, selecting, freezing, and storing mushrooms. We are always keen on learning from you too! So, if you have a better alternative to store a big amount of mushrooms, tell us your secret. Also, don’t hesitate to ask all your further questions in the comments section. Mutual help is what we are here for! Not to mention that some readers might just inspire by all your constructive questions and advice. So, shout out your thoughts and opinion!

Also, if this post was helpful to you, Pin It to your Pinterest Library for later!

How To Freeze Mushrooms
Website | + posts

Katy Willis is a writer, lifelong homesteader, and master herbalist, master gardener, and canine nutritionist. Katy is a preparedness expert and modern homesteader practicing everyday preparedness, sustainability, and a holistic lifestyle.

She knows how important it is to be prepared for whatever life throws at you, because you just never know what's coming. And preparedness helps you give your family the best chance to thrive in any situation.

Katy is passionate about living naturally, growing food, keeping livestock, foraging, and making and using herbal remedies. Katy is an experienced herbalist and a member of the CMA (Complementary Medical Association).

Her preparedness skills go beyond just being "ready", she's ready to survive the initial disaster, and thrive afterward, too. She grows 100% organic food on roughly 15 acres and raises goats, chickens, and ducks. She also lovingly tends her orchard, where she grows many different fruit trees. And, because she likes to know exactly what she's feeding her family, she's a seasoned from-scratch cook and gluten-free baker.

Katy teaches foraging and environmental education classes, too, including self-sufficient living, modern homesteading, seed saving, and organic vegetable gardening.

Katy helps others learn forgotten skills, including basic survival skills and self-reliance.

She's been published on sites such as MSN, Angi, Home Advisor, Family Handyman, Wealth of Geeks, Readers Digest, and more.

Leave a Comment